If I haven’t seemed like my normally garrulous self lately, it’s because what with teaching 5 classes, editing a book, and writing a dissertation, I’ve been a little low on though-juice. Because one can never have too much to worry about, though, I’ve taken on a new class for the Spring, People and Culture of the World, which is what it sounds like (this is at the community college level, by the way). Since I wasn’t actually told about this until the Spring catalog came out (said my chair, “Oh, didn’t I tell you?”) I’m under a lot of pressure to get book orders in. I’ve got a textbook selected (John Bodley’s Cultural Anthropology: Tribes, States, and the Global System, though I’m also trying to get a review copy of Core Concepts in Cultural Anthropology to use when I teach the class again) but I could use some help selecting a couple of short(-ish?) case studies — 2 or 3 books around 150 pages to supplement the shorter cultural descriptions in Bodley’s book. I’d like one of these to deal with a Muslim culture, especially (though not necessarily) if it deals with gender; then I’m thinking either a foraging people or South Pacific horticultural group, and maybe a minority subculture in a polycultural industrial state. Since I don’t really have time to go through the full process of requesting a dozen or so exam copies to review, waiting for them to arrive, and carefully evaluating them, I’m hoping that the collective wisdom of the Savage Minds collective can point me in the right direction — at least to help me narrow my choices down so I don’t waste time on outdated, unteachable, or poorly written ethnographies.
So how about it — any suggestions? Also, as long as we’re on the topic, what do you think of these kinds of works, you know: those short books clearly intended for introductory-level classes? What other sorts of books do you think might be appropriate for this sort of class? And how do you go about evaluating texts for your classes (if you’re a teacher of some sort, that is)? What are you looking for, and how do you know when you found it?
A former acquaintance, Kiri Miller, is conducting “a study at the University of Alberta on radio stations in Grand Theft Auto”:http://www.ualberta.ca/~kmmiller/gtasurvey.html. If you’ve ever played GTA and listened to the radio, please spread the word about the survey and fill it out yourself!
A friend of a friend is doing a project anthropology and blogging in France and asked me to pass on a request — is there a French anthropology group blog that is functionally equivalent to Savage Minds? Or in general are there any French anthropology blogs that people can particularly reccomend? I know there are some EHESSians amongst our readers…
Back in the day young anthropologistswent off to the field packing a copy of the Notes and Queries in Anthropology — a checklist of topics About Their People that they had to be sure to cover. The idea was that there were people back in the metropole were creating generalizing theories of society and needed comparative data to do it. You might be studying ritual and myth amongst the Pukapukaese, but someone out there was trying to plot the distribution of outrigger canoes, and they wanted to make sure you added your two bits. Thus the notes and queries included standard questions to ask, and diagrams of bows and so forth with the English names for bits of the bow so that you could describe in English what people were telling you Pukapukian. I can testify that having the Notes and Queries in the field is useful — in a fit of retropique I took one with me to the field, and it did in fact help me keep my eyes open in ways I wouldn’t have otherwise: how people carried babies, how often crops came up and so forth — the kind of thing I might otherwise have not thought about.
Today the Notes and Queries is out of print, but would like to keep it’s tradition alive in another modality — I want to create a Notes and Queries for virtual worlds, and I want to ask you what you think ought to be in it?
Like the Oxford dons who gathered their ethnographic data through correspondence with railroad clerks and bank tellers living in outstations in rural Australia, anthropology professors today who are interested in massively multiplayer video games have a pool of indigenous experts to draw on: their students. Profs all over the place have encountered students whose reflective awareness of the game’s they’ve mastered means that they have in some sense become avocational anthropologists themselves. In my “anthropology of virtual worlds class”:http://alex.golub.name/res/HPUAnthro3830Fall2005.pdf this semester my students will be producing a series of ethnographic papers about the virtual worlds that they have been studying, and several of them are interested in publishing them on the web. What, then, are the categories and comparisons that you think they should highlight in their paper?
Some might object that when ‘the field’ is only a click away, profs are not completely out of the loop. While I don’t have 7 level 60s on three different WOW servers, I play often enough that I understand the differences in the economy and sociology of, say, Guild Wars and Diablo II that is wrought by their differing use of instancing. And in fact my familiarity is part of the problem — so many of the researchers who study virtual worlds sort of ‘already know’ about how these worlds are structured that we often end up assuming that ‘merely’ descriptive pieces are uninteresting. We assume that we already know all about these games because we play them all the time. But what about people who — like the typical anthropological audience — want to know all about these places, but aren’t ever going to end up going there themselves? And surely sometimes we as natives of these spaces need someone to write down what is going on in them — that is why we have historians and journalists and so forth in real life.
So: We need to begin developing a corpus of richly ehtnographic writing about virtual worlds, and we need to structure it in such a way that we can compare the cases with each other. What are the categories we are interest in? What form should they take? What sorts of notes and queries should be made? What is on your radar? The way the architecture of the game mandates cooperation? The way the virtual worlds are becoming ‘third places’ for students? Let me know what you would want out of a comparative study.
I recently received this e-mail from the Institute of International Education:
Following please find an announcement concerning new fellowships for threatened scholars. Scholars from any country and any field may qualify. We invite you to nominate suitable candidates, and ask for your help in forwarding the announcement to any academic colleagues who may be interested. We are especially eager to identify candidates still facing threats in their home country/region, who may not be aware of the program. At the same time, we invite participation from universities and colleges that might be willing to host fellowship recipients. We are especially eager to identify universities and colleges outside of the US, especially French, Spanish and Russian language institutions.
Visit the web site for more information.
Daniel M.T. Fessler, Assoc. Professor of Anthropology at UCLA, is requesting data on children’s interactions with fire in small-scale societies. If you are able to, please respond to his survey, copied in full below the fold. Send your response directly to Dan (dmtfessler “at” gmail.com) – do not post in the comments or he might not get them.